This debt doc brings Margaret Atwood by way of Jennifer Baichwal

The effects of the Gulf of Mexico oilspill are discussed in Payback, playing at Cinecenta Sun., March 25 to Sat., March 31.

The effects of the Gulf of Mexico oilspill are discussed in Payback, playing at Cinecenta Sun., March 25 to Sat., March 31.


Despite sounding like one of those one-word-title action flicks (in fact it was, a dozen years ago), the new Payback is a thoughtful and provocative documentary. It also has an impressive pedigree, having started out as a series of Massey Lectures by Margaret Atwood that became the book Payback: Debt and the Shadow Side of Wealth that then became the inspiration for acclaimed documentary filmmaker Jennifer Baichwal (Manufactured Landscapes).

The subject of Atwood’s lectures was “debt” in all its forms; early in the film she says that doing the lectures was an opportunity for her to explore a topic that she didn’t really understand. The starting point was “debt as an intellectual construct,” and her inquiries were wide-ranging to the point of digressive. Baichwal happily takes up the challenge and introduces us first to a Hatfield-versus-McCoy feud in Albania that, according to their laws, amounts to a lethal blood debt. The second related theme involves a criminal’s debt to society: the camera pans over the scabby walls and cramped cells of America’s first penitentiary, then begins an interview with celebrity convict Conrad Black, who pontificates with surprising compassion about the mostly-abandoned constituency of prison inmates and the failings of the criminal justice system.

The enquiry expands further when we meet a remorseful criminal who is in jail for breaking into a woman’s house to steal stuff to support a drug habit that started when he was a teenager growing up on the streets. Then it’s off to the tomato-growing fields of Florida where some recent court cases have revealed that many indentured farm labourers from Mexico are brutalized like slaves — this called a form of political debt. The final category involves the eco-exploitation that modern capitalist society perpetrates with an ever-more-ravenous appetite. Whether it’s the recent BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico or our rabid over-consumption of natural resources, the simple but compelling metaphor is that we owe a debt to the Earth we may not be able to repay.

Despite the often loosey-goosey nature of this wide-ranging inquiry, the journey Baichwal takes us on is fascinating — and sometimes unexpectedly inter-related. The comments about how being isolated in prison was originally supposed to make a criminal “penitent” find a cruder contemporary echo in Albania, where a man who wounded a neighbour has to stay permanently on his property or else can be killed by the offended party. And the image of someone eating a tomato a thousand miles beyond the sight of the human degradation that brought it to market at a “cheap” price is suddenly parallel to a hapless pelican covered in shit-brown oil. Whether we are having a tasty salad at the expense of cruelly exploited labour or fill up a car with tainted gas, we all carry a large burden of unacknowledged debt.

The extended Albanian footage adds up to less than the sum of its parts, while some of the bold environmental claims are not supported by any form of proof or argument. But the divergent narrative strands are woven together quite wonderfully at the climax of the film. And despite the oft-bleak content, Debt contains a surprising amount of optimism. Fans of serious cinema will want to see this one. M


Payback ★★★

Directed by Jennifer Baichwal

Starring Margaret Atwood

86 minutes, runs at UVic’s Cinecenta

Sun., March 25 to Sat., March 31



After watching this challenging but engrossing film, you’ve earned yourself a treat. Buffalo Trace is a gourmet bourbon that boasts a complex array of flavours that include winter spices, vanilla, oak and dried fruit. Its long finish has a fiery elegance reminiscent of cognac. At $40, a worthy splurge.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Artist Daniel Cline discusses his sculpture, Harmony Humpbacks, during the June 20 walking tour of Oak Bay’s 2019 ArtsAlive sculptures. Harmony Humpbacks was purchased by Oak Bay as the 2019 people’s choice winner and is permanently installed at the Beach Drive entrance to Willows Park. (Kevin Murdoch Photo)
Influx of donated art a ‘fantastic problem to have,’ says Oak Bay mayor

Oak Bay goes from zero to 10 permanent art pieces since 2015

Tomo Vranjes, a Greater Victoria musician and longtime fan of late rock guitar icon Eddie Van Halen, joins artist Paul Archer behind the latter’s Fort Street gallery. Archer, whose airbrushed paintings of rock greats have made him many connections in recent years, painted a likeness of Van Halen following the guitarist’s death last month from cancer. (Don Descoteau/News Staff)
Victoria artist’s king-sized tribute to Eddie Van Halen draws on personal connection

Paul Archer had an up close and personal day with the legendary guitarist in 1980

The Vancouver Island Symphony’s Back Row Brass Quintet – including trumpeter Mark D’Angelo, tuba player Nick Atkinson and French horn player Karen Hough (from left) – were scheduled to tour the Nanaimo area with Christmas Under the Big Tent, but the concert series has now been cancelled. (Photo courtesy HA Photography)
Symphony brass quintet’s Christmas concert series cancelled

Performances were to happen at venues in Parksville and Lantzville next month

The Sheringham Point Lighthouse, near Shirley. (Contributed - Lee-Ann Ruttan)
New book shines a light on Sheringham Point Lighthouse

Publication examines history, lightkeepers, and volunteer society

Victoria-based guitarist Eric Harper performs at the Port Theatre on Nov. 27. (Photo credit Tatum Duryba)
Classical guitarist to play at the Port Theatre

Eric Harper to play new songs composed during the pandemic

A sample of some of Lou-ann Neel’s jewelry.
Lou-ann Neel wins the Fulmer Award in First Nations Art

Originally from Alert Bay, Neel’s family is steeped in renowned Kwakwaka’wakw artists

I-Hos Gallery manager Ramona Johnson shows some of the paddles available at the retail outlet. Photo by Terry Farrell
I-Hos Gallery celebrates 25 years of promoting First Nation artwork

K’ómoks First Nation-based outlet has art from all over the country

Bard to Broadway Theatre Society may stage shows outdoors next summer. (PQB News photo file)
Qualicum Beach’s Bard to Broadway group may stage shows outdoors

Theatre society plans smaller productions due to ongoing pandemic

A new short film festival called MORVENFEST is encouraging B.C. secondary students to step into the world of film during their Christmas break. (Jane Skrypnek/News Staff)
New film festival gives Victoria students exciting opportunity

MORVENFEST is open to all B.C. secondary students over Christmas break

Most Read