The documentary Three Identical Strangers tells the story of triplets raised in different families who discovered each other at age 19. On at UVic’s Cinecenta through Aug. 4. Photo courtesy Neon

The documentary Three Identical Strangers tells the story of triplets raised in different families who discovered each other at age 19. On at UVic’s Cinecenta through Aug. 4. Photo courtesy Neon

ON FILM: The Trouble With Triplets

Robert Moyes had great fun with Three Identical Strangers, closing Aug. 4 at UVic’s Cinecenta

It was 1980 and 19-year-old Bobby Shafran was walking onto his college campus in the Catskills for the very first time.

Weirdly, many people were incredibly friendly to him and one young woman even gave him a kiss. Things started to make sense when a freaked-out guy said that Bobby was a perfect look-alike for a good friend of his named Eddy. When it turned out that both young men were adopted, courtesy of the same agency, it was quickly confirmed that identical twins had been unexpectedly reunited.

The resulting “ain’t life strange” news story soon flushed out a third 19-year-old, David Kellman, who turned the twins into triplets – and launched a media circus ranging from TV appearances on the Mike Douglas Show to cover stories on Time and Good Housekeeping.

Welcome to Three Identical Strangers, an award-winning documentary from Tim Wardle, who spent five years figuring out how to tell a twist-filled and increasingly dark tale that had stymied several earlier directors who tried and failed to find a narrative structure for this jaw-dropping story.

The film starts with contemporary “talking head” conversations with two of the brothers, personable interviewees whose engaging and remarkable tale is supplemented by re-enactments and archival footage.

The first half of Identical is wonderfully engaging: from finding out that all three sweet-as-puppies brothers wrestled in high school, to being told that they all smoke Marlboro cigarettes and have similar taste in women; the deep imprint of their genetic legacy is revealed in humorous ways.

“They were more like clones than brothers,” chuckled one friend. And aside from their own anecdotes, various adoptive parents and wives also contribute appealing recollections. We also see a clip of their cameo with Madonna in the 1985 comedy Desperately Seeking Susan. Human-interest stories just don’t get more compelling.

And we’re now at the point in the review where no more details should be revealed. Suffice it to say that Wardle upshifts to investigative journalist, and Identical segues from cute to creepy with a gobsmacking turn to the dark side that I doubt very few viewers could ever possibly anticipate.

Wardle is a thoughtful man and he ultimately uses the unique story of these three men to explore some profound questions about science and morality that will challenge the audience. Don’t miss this one!

Rating: ****

NOTE: Runs at UVic’s Cinecenta through Aug. 4

Directed by Tim Wardle

COMING SOON:

The Spy Who Dumped Me –SNL’s Kate McKinnon and Mila Kunis are best friends unexpectedly thrust into the middle of a muddle of murderous spyjinks. Cue the comedy!

The Meg – Mega tough guy Jason Statham (Transporter) goes up against a Megalodon, the 75-foot, 40-ton prehistoric ancestor to the great white shark. Take that, Steven Spielberg!

BlacKkKlansman – The latest from Spike Lee is a true-life crime thriller about the efforts of a couple of brave undercover cops to take down the KKK in the 1970s. With Adam Driver.

Mile 22 – Action guy Mark Wahlberg stars as a CIA field operative who has to team up with an Indonesian police officer in order to vanquish some extremely violent political corruption.

Film ReviewsRobert Moyes

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

VIU’s ‘Portal’ magazine is turning 30 years old. (Image courtesy Chantelle Calitz)
Vancouver Island University’s literary magazine ‘Portal’ celebrates 30 years

Virtual launch featuring contributor readings took place April 30

Nanaimo author Haley Healey recently launched her second book, ‘Flourishing and Free: More Stories of Trailblazing Women of Vancouver Island.’ (Photo courtesy Kristin Wenberg)
Nanaimo author pens second book on ‘trailblazing’ Vancouver Island women

Haley Healey’s ‘Flourishing and Free’ follows her 2020 debut ‘On Their Own Terms’

Saanich author Hannalora Leavitt hopes her new book, This Disability Experience, helps to dispel the ‘otherness’ that often surrounds people with disabilities. (Jane Skrypnek/News Staff)
Vancouver Island author demystifying disability and dismantling otherness

Hannalora Leavitt, who lives with a visual impairment, wants to change how people look at disability

Michael Demers, performing here as a member of The Lonely, died May 1 after a year-long battle with leukemia. (Photo by Benji Duke)
Victoria music community mourning Michael Demers

Veteran singer-songwriter, co-founder of The Lonely dies at 63 due to leukemia

The Royal B.C. Museum has added a tamba dining set, used by a Punjabi man on his voyage to Canada in 1927, to its ‘100 Objects of Interest’ online collection. (Courtesy of Royal B.C. Museum)
Punjabi dining set added to Royal B.C. Museum’s ‘100 Objects of Interest’ collection

Set used by Indar Singh Gill on his voyage from Punjab to Canada in 1927

Musqueam and Qualicum First Nations artist, Mathew Andreatta, next to several of his ongoing projects, including carvings and illustrations. (Submitted photo)
Island artist considers art a means to reconnect with his Indigenous identity

Andreatta thought of TOSH as a space of learning and creation

Nicolle Nattrass and Michael Armstrong are presenting an online reading on May 9. (Photos courtesy Joni Marcolin/Heather Armstrong)
Nanaimo playwrights present online Mother’s Day script readings

Nicolle Nattrass and Michael Armstrong to read from in-progress plays

Marianne Turley is one of this year’s City of Nanaimo Culture and Heritage Award winners for Honour in Culture. (Bulletin file photo)
Longtime Vancouver Island Symphony board member gets posthumous culture award

Marianne Turley receives City of Nanaimo Culture and Heritage Award for Honour in Culture

The CVAC Fine Arts Show is always something to see and 2021 promises to be no different, as they adopt a fully multimedia approach. (File photo)
Cowichan Valley Fine Arts Show goes multimedia for 2021

The show, which runs from May 1-22 will be available both in person and online.

Dinner After a Death, a painting by Sooke artist Bryan Cathcart is part of a collection featuring his work at the Outsiders and Others Gallery in Vancouver. (Contributed - Bryan Cathcart)
Sooke artist finds creativity by expanding artistic horizons

Bryan Cathcart, 26, featured at Vancouver gallery

Viking-inspired fantasy writer Joshua Gillingham of Nanaimo and Seattle-based Islamic science fiction editor Muhammad Aurangzeb Ahmad are co-editing ‘Althingi – The Crescent and the Northern Star.’ (Photos submitted, illustration by Lada Shustova/Figue)
Nanaimo author co-editing historical anthology connecting Vikings and Muslims

Joshua Gilligham presents ‘Althingi – The Crescent and the Northern Star’

Saltair-based writer, Krista May. (Janet Kelly photo)
Island writers make long-list for 2021 CBC Short Story Prize

Krista May and Angie Ellis among 33 finalists selected out of over 3,000 entrants

Most Read