Letter – An existential masterpiece

Re: “Unmeaningful pretension,” Letters, June 30-July 6

An existential masterpiece

Re: “Unmeaningful pretension,” Letters, June 30-July 6

I’ve had my disagreements with Robert Moyes over the years, but regarding Malick’s “The Tree of Life,” the Monday film critic nails it, whereas Monday reader Stephen Potter doesn’t even see the nail, much less hit it. I doubt Potter is even equipped with a hammer could he locate the nail.

Put aside the fact “Tree of Life,” winner of the prestigious Palme D’Or at Cannes, has received praise from just about every film critic who matters. The fact is, Malick, who puts about 10 years worth of thought and consideration into a single film, is about as far from the “flatland of star-addled Hollywood” as a director could get, and “Tree of Life” is refreshingly indicative of this fact. This film, in my humble view, is an existential masterpiece of subtle, yet profound proportions, which may be a bit too weighty for Potter, who sees only “shallow pretension.”

As for the claim of “meaningless art,” what did he hope for in a Malick film? More superheroes, car explosions, indiscriminate violence, Jackass stunts in 3D, comic books on the big screen and saccharine plot formula? “Tree of Life” requires one to actually think for a change at the cinema.  Malick’s filmmaking style is unique, akin to visual poetry, which I concede may numb today’s attention-deficit, blockbuster movie-goers.

Great works of art have always effectively divided an audience, creating the conditions for debate and dialectical ferment. The dividing lines are often many, but one of those lines is between those who get it and those who do not.

Peter Tolman,Victoria

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

The Royal B.C. Museum has added a tamba dining set, used by a Punjabi man on his voyage to Canada in 1927, to its ‘100 Objects of Interest’ online collection. (Courtesy of Royal B.C. Museum)
Punjabi dining set added to Royal B.C. Museum’s ‘100 Objects of Interest’ collection

Set used by Indar Singh Gill on his voyage from Punjab to Canada in 1927

Victoria-born musician Bryce Dane Soderberg took to Instagram Monday to call out the Greater Victoria School District on its proposed cuts to elementary and middle school music programs. (Bryce Dane Soderberg/Instagram)
Victoria-born Lifehouse vocalist calls out SD61 on proposed music cuts

‘It will be a big loss to future generations’ Bryce Dane Soderberg posted to his Instagram

Ballet Victoria is honouring Rosemarie Liscum, the president of the board of directors who was instrumental in the building the dance company. Liscum died earlier this month. (Photo courtesy of Ballet Victoria)
Rosemarie Liscum remembered as dedicated, instrumental builder of Victoria Ballet

The president of the ballet company’s board of directors died at the age of 59

Marianne Turley is one of this year’s City of Nanaimo Culture and Heritage Award winners for Honour in Culture. (Bulletin file photo)
Longtime Vancouver Island Symphony board member gets posthumous culture award

Marianne Turley receives City of Nanaimo Culture and Heritage Award for Honour in Culture

The CVAC Fine Arts Show is always something to see and 2021 promises to be no different, as they adopt a fully multimedia approach. (File photo)
Cowichan Valley Fine Arts Show goes multimedia for 2021

The show, which runs from May 1-22 will be available both in person and online.

Dinner After a Death, a painting by Sooke artist Bryan Cathcart is part of a collection featuring his work at the Outsiders and Others Gallery in Vancouver. (Contributed - Bryan Cathcart)
Sooke artist finds creativity by expanding artistic horizons

Bryan Cathcart, 26, featured at Vancouver gallery

Viking-inspired fantasy writer Joshua Gillingham of Nanaimo and Seattle-based Islamic science fiction editor Muhammad Aurangzeb Ahmad are co-editing ‘Althingi – The Crescent and the Northern Star.’ (Photos submitted, illustration by Lada Shustova/Figue)
Nanaimo author co-editing historical anthology connecting Vikings and Muslims

Joshua Gilligham presents ‘Althingi – The Crescent and the Northern Star’

Saltair-based writer, Krista May. (Janet Kelly photo)
Island writers make long-list for 2021 CBC Short Story Prize

Krista May and Angie Ellis among 33 finalists selected out of over 3,000 entrants

A writer studying in England drew from her roots growing up in Sooke for a story that’s been short-listed for a prestigious international prize.
Former Sooke resident up for prestigious writing award

Cara Marks earns nomination for the 2021 Commonwealth Short Story Prize

Three Legged Dog Productions performed Jesus Christ Superstar in 2019. Tim Penney photo
Non-profit plans musical renaissance in the Comox Valley

Three Legged Dog Productions is preparing for a summer residency at Filberg Park

View Gallery curator Chai Duncan admires the work of graduating visual art student Hailin Zhang, one of the artists in the upcoming End Marks grad show. (Josef Jacobson/News Bulletin)
VIU visual art grad show presented as virtual gallery tour due to COVID-19

‘End Marks’ exhibition is on display from April 29 to May 30

Most Read