Joaquin Phoenix gives a haunting and violent portrayal of a traumatized war vet who hires himself out as a rescuer of runaway and kidnapped girls. Amazon Studios

FILM REVIEW: Violent vigilanteism helps cast disquieting spell

Robert Moyes offers his take on Joaquin Phoenix and You Were Never Here

Robert Moyes

Monday Magazine contributor

Unabashedly non-commercial director Lynne Ramsay (We Need to Talk About Kevin) doubles down with her newest film, You Were Never Really Here.

Imagine an elliptical, feminist, art-house update of Taxi Driver and you’ve got a pretty good idea what she’s doing here as she enters almost exclusively male territory to re-invent the vigilante genre.

A bearded and mumbly Joaquin Phoenix stars as Joe, whose back story – an abusive childhood and some dreadful experiences as a soldier – you are obliged to piece together on the fly as Ramsay doles out fragmented flashbacks. Joe seems to suffer from PTSD but he’s still keen to hire himself out as a brutal, ball peen hammer-wielding rescuer of girls who are either runaways or kidnap victims. Adding to the psychological complexity, Joe is an unconventional caregiver to his semi-demented mother.

A senator’s 14-year-old daughter has ended up a prisoner in a house of horrors where rich men pay to have sex with under-age girls. “Hurt them a lot,” demands the senator when he meets covertly with Joe to hire him. Joe is happy to oblige, and his visit to the rape-house yields brutal results. But the sequence never becomes viscerally exciting action porn because the punishment – meted out to customers and guards alike – is distanced by being shown via static surveillance-camera footage that is part of the house’s security system.

Joe’s rescue of the traumatized girl is short-lived, however, as murderous violence descends upon him from an unexpected direction. With the girl once again missing, the plot suddenly involves a conspiracy whose puzzling dimensions aren’t made clear until almost the end of the film.

Never is often opaque and makes few concessions to the audience: the violence isn’t cathartic, enigmatic Joe remains shrouded in emotional darkness, and even when the plot comes to a climax there is still much left unresolved. In other words, this won’t be selling a lot of popcorn at the cineplex.

That said, the creatively directed Never should be of interest to those film fans who usually have no appetite for the bone-crunching mayhem that Hollywood’s more manly directors like to ladle out. And the gloomy and harsh soundtrack by Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood adds an effectively disturbing element. Although Never never tries to gratuitously shock the audience, it does cast a deeply disquieting spell.

Rating: ***1/2

Stars Joaquin Phoenix

Directed by Lynne Ramsay

COMING SOON:

On Chesil Beach

Based on the Ian McEwan novella, this drama is set in 1962 and explores the societal and sexual pressures on a mismatched young couple as they head towards their fateful wedding night. Starring Saoirse Ronan.

Deadpool 2

Ryan Reynolds once again rat-a-tats out profane – and hysterically funny – one-liners in a sequel to the delightfully smart and bizarre superhero comedy that was one of the biggest hits of 2016.

The Seagull

This adaptation of Chekov’s drama about the volatile and fragile nature of love has been relocated to rural New England and stars Annette Bening and Saoirse Ronan.

Tully

Academy Award winner Charlize Theron plays a stressed-to-the-max mother of three whose unexpected saviour is an intriguing young nanny named Tully.

Book Club

This provocative comedy stars Diane Keaton, Jane Fonda, and Candice Bergen as divorced women in a book club who start to make outrageous life choices after reading 50 Shades of Grey.

Future World

In a post-apocalyptic world various dire adventures befall such stars as James Franco, Lucy Liu and Milla Jovovich.

Film Reviews

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Vancouver Island dance classes billed as female empowerment tool

New Comox Valley business focuses on ‘promoting positive body image’

Duncan’s Big Stick lights up red to signal COVID’s devastation of the arts

“COVID-19 has been truly devastating to the Cowichan Performing Arts Centre”

Pandemic reunites 2000s era Victoria rock band The Origin

Saanich musicians recording for first time since 2008

From Nanoose Bay to the bookshelf, Howard the Gnome now a children’s book

Vancouver Island author explores Howard’s move down-Island

Nanaimo country singer releases new music video

‘Adrenaline’ is the second single from Joel Lee’s upcoming debut EP

Nanaimo musician plays all instruments on DIY debut album

Jamie Penner releasing guitar-centric instrumental record ‘Out of Curiosity’

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

Hospice worker and patient butt heads in upcoming Nanaimo theatre production

Yellow Point Drama Group presents ‘Grace and Glorie’ at Cedar Community Hall

Art+Earth Festival gets growing this weekend

Find out what events are in-person and what’s happening online

Film about missing and murdered indigenous women makes Nanaimo debut

A mother and daughter search for answers in Sonia Bonspille Boileau’s ‘Rustic Oracle’

Nanaimo’s Harbour City Photography Club goes virtual to adapt to COVID-19

Club’s exhibitions, meetings and presentations are now occurring online

Nanaimo’s Western Edge Theatre returns to the stage in Port Theatre debut

Theatre group presents ‘2 Across,’ described as a ‘middle-aged romantic comedy’

Authors nominated for Victoria Book Prize awards

Finalists for 2020 announced in two categories

Most Read