Movie Review: The Great Gatsby

The Great Gatsby is a not-so-great retelling of the popular novel

Leonardo DiCaprio stars in The (not-so) Great Gatsby

Although the trailers for Baz (Moulin Rouge) Luhrmann’s adaptation of The Great Gatsby contained a threateningly large quantity of eye-popping razzle-dazzle, the film is, at least by Lurhmann’s standards, a relatively subdued affair. F. Scott Fitzgerald’s iconic Jazz Age novel that critiqued the modern American soul continues to sell in the hundreds of thousands, and on paper Luhrmann seemed a good choice to adapt this rather symbolic tale of a naïve Midwesterner dragged into the opulent homes and decadent lives of a group of self-absorbed Long Island socialites.

Surprisingly, this tragic tale of love, greed, and power is rarely emotionally involving, while its principal characters are mostly uninteresting. Tobey Maguire as the Fitzgerald-esque narrator who recalls the story in flashback is the only person who seems to break through the film’s stylized façade. The usually excellent Carey Mulligan (An Education), playing the limp but beautiful narcissist caught between two powerful millionaires, makes for a rather dazed Daisy. And Leonardo DiCaprio’s performance as the eponymous Jay Gatsby has a few compelling moments but mostly seems self-conscious (and after the first hundred utterances of “old sport,” couldn’t he have given it a rest?). As is often the case, you’re better off staying home and reading the book. M

 

The Great Gatsby  ★★½

Directed by Baz Luhrmann

Starring Leonardo DiCaprio, Richard Carter

PG 13 – 154 minutes • Continues at The Empire 6,

WestShore, SilverCity, Uni 4 and the Star

 

Just Posted

Bill Gaston, Monique Gray Smith capture Victoria Book Prizes for 2018

Butler Book Prize and Bolen Books Children’s Book Prize winners collect $5,000 each

Canada’s country music sweetheart brings The Gumboot Kids to town

Jessie Farrell to perform songs from her hit CBC TV series at McTavish Academy of Arts

VIFF wrap-up: Finely crafted films part of festival finale

Monday reviewer Kyle Wells puts a cap on his 2018 Vancouver International Film Festival experience

FILM REVIEWS: Race relations, refugees and racy romances featured at VIFF

Monday reviewer Kyle Wells presents round 2 from the Vancouver International Film Fest

An eye for art: The new and the notable at fall’s premier arts event

Sidney Fine Art Show shares wealth of Island talent Oct. 11 to 13

WATCH: Twelve Angry Jurors puts a new spin on an old tale

Canadian College of Performing Arts opens season with reworked version of Reginald Rose teleplay

WATCH: Twelve Angry Jurors puts a new spin on an old tale

Canadian College of Performing Arts opens season with reworked version of Reginald Rose teleplay

INDY FILM FARE: 1970s hedonism and more at The Vic Theatre

From Studio 54 to Rocky Horror, there’s plenty of excess to observe this month

Shark-attack metal band coming to Victoria tonight

Shark Infested Daughters, a Calgary metalcore group, play the Upstairs Cabaret tonight, Oct. 13

STAGE AND SONG: Spotlight on Victoria arts groups

Learn about some of the city’s favourite theatre and musical entertainment options

Island lensman Jim Decker lands three top photography awards

During exciting photo trip to Yap in Micronesia, Cobble Hill man earns trio of firsts

Celebrate Oktoberfest Stein and Dine at the Victoria Public Market

Food, suds and German-style fun on tap at Oct. 20 event

Most Read